Saturday, May 05, 2007

Drinking is bad, Its a Sin?

Recently I found myself in middle of the following conversation.
Lady Friend: Do you Drink?
Me: Yes, Why?
And I could see her face change. As if those expressions said, "Drinking is bad, Its a Sin.". I didn't extend the conversation because harder I would have tried to explain that "Drinking" as normal act more it would have looked like a "Justification of my so called Sin".

Being in Goa for last 25 years. The place is so much influenced by western culture, that drinking alcohol never came to me as a cultural shock. No one ever argued about drinking as good or bad act neither anyone insisted others to have or to stop drinking. Over the years being in goa, the implication, "Boozing implies addict/hitting wife/vomit/bad-mouthing/lying in gutter" never occurred to me as such examples were rare compared to number of people I had seen drinking. May be its because of the maturity of a particular community towards a particular aspect of life.

But certainly that gaze of my friend still confuses me. I pondered alot not for "Justification of an act" but rather to take it to a level above. Coming back to the original question, "Is Drinking bad/sin?". Hmmm... Certainly the word "bad" in itself is relative and solely depends upon an individuals perspective . But still taking a step ahead, I would say an act is bad if that act results in physical/mental anguish of society or group of people or of an individual himself. And in my opinion a person who is an occasional drinker hardly indulges himself in any activity which is hurtful to the society or an individual. OK. The above explanation may seem like a justification. In which case lets talk about something else. Lets consider work. "Is working bad?". Certainly not. That's the most creative and constructive thing to do. But is it always the case. Have you ever encountered an Workaholic? A person who is so passionate about his work, that he spends 12-14 hours working (certainly there many of them in IT industry.) Do they do justice to their own physical/mental health or the health of their family and society. The statistics say that, the rate of suicide, divorce and impotency is the most in IT industry and cause being the workload and competition. So working hard is bad?

The point is how well a person knows where and when to stop. Let it be work, playing. Internet gaming, love, emotions, orkutting, chatting and for that matter drinking. By their inception they are not bad, its an inability of a person to control their actions is where the problem lies.

In my opinion people take "Drinking" at its face value. You would see a person fully drunk lying beside road-side and happily conclude "all drinkers are the same". But one would never peep into a devastated lovers heart and say "No one should fall in love". You would not see fights in Workaholics home and stop putting extra hours at work. You will never understand the depression of "gaming freak" and stop playing minesweeper. No doubt addiction is bad but it does not make the act itself ruinous.

Recently I happened to interact with gals and most of them were of strong opinion that their to be husband would be "Non-drinkers". Its very much same as when guy say my to be wife would be with "Good looks and figure". Certainly both are the wrong means of judging a person. I always feel tempted to tell these gals please think of maturity and integrity of man before having "Non-drinker" specification on their list. Its certainly worth being with a man who knows the difference rather then a man who is ignorant about it.

7 Comments:

Blogger Dhananjay said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

2:47 AM  
Blogger sarvagnaani said...

>Being in Goa for last 25 years. The place is so much influenced by western culture, that drinking alcohol never came to me as a cultural shock.
The exact reason why people, esp those with 'traditional' background feel so strongly about drinking, except the feeling is of course antipathy (hehe..learnt a new word :D )

going by your definition of 'bad', drinking in excess is bad, we agree on that.But drinking in controlled amounts is also bad, for your health, and this is something that can be avoided. Drinking is not a 'must'.

Also, some 'justification' of why ppl tend to generalize and happily conclude "all drinkers are the same"..you get high after you drink..and speaking from the experiences of my friends, being 'high' is pleasurable..and somewhat easily attainable state(drinking doesnt take much effort..does it?)..so there is a high chance that a drinking person will turn into a drunkard..

coming to the point of girls saying, i want a non-drinker..let us see..why do ppl drink? to put it straight..to get high..isnt it?and ppl who get high, most of the times end up talking not much of sense, walking in a weird style.. in general..make fools of themselves..no person would like to see another person close to him/her 'deliberately'(remember,drinking is not a must) making fool of himself..more so, if it is a girl and the person is her spouse..this is one more reason apart from the health point that i said..

one comment about your comparison with working long hours..I dont think its a fair comparison..no 'commonman' would like to be a put in extra long hours, he is being forced..due to deadlines, the moral responsibility of owning the task, and the money that he gets paid..compare this with the 'willfull' submission to drinking..i guess they are contrasting..ofcourse, if the person is passionate about work, then thats a different story..but then again..what is the ratio of such ppl in the industry?

and the last point about non drinkers being ignorant..its the way you look at it..consider this..a person who willfully makes a fool of himself and embarasses ppl around him and causes harm to his health(man..my eng is screwed..so many 'and's in one sentence), all this to get a high which lasts for few minutes..do you think that is a very mature act?
again..it is not the case that non-drinker did not have the chance to get a high..he chose not to..dont you think this is mature?

3:35 AM  
Blogger Dhananjay said...

Good analysis and thinking! Jokes apart, myself was very scared of drinkers and smokers till I was in 12th. When went to engg, saw a few individuals who drink/smoke and are exceptionally good human beings in all aspects of life. I never drunk because somebody forced me to or asked to have.
About the matrimonial specification criterian - ppl have very strong opinions about alcohol and can not think the other way round which is may be becoz of the social surroundings. E.g. I can never think something good about Himesh's music but there would be something becoz a good number of ppl are his fans.
I don't go in the debate of whether drinking is good/bad because it is hard to change somebody's strong opinions.

3:48 AM  
Blogger Aniket said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

4:25 AM  
Blogger Aniket said...

Nowhere in the blog I tried to justify drinking as good or bad act. People have strong prejudice and misconceptions about drinkers some of them are strongly reflected in Kumar's reply. Most of these prejudice are false.

I do not hold the capability to convenience or to eliminate these misconceptions. But do wish an individual finds his/her own way to look beyond these prejudice.

Unfortunately, if you think a person drinking would always land up making fool of himself then I would say you have met wrong bunch of drinkers :P

Final Note : Occasional Drinking is good for health.
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0857/is_n2_v13/ai_16896755

4:28 AM  
Blogger Phoenix said...

Buddy! A fantastic angle / perspective on the concept of "bad" and "good". Drinking and Work are just reasons to bring forth the beauty of the human nature surrounding the words.!
Just like "control" is just a state of mind and nothing ever is in control!

10:46 AM  
Blogger Soham Pablo said...

Visited your blog after ages. This is a great piece. I liked the last reference comparing "non-drinkers" to "good looks and figure" :D

4:04 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home